The current U.S. administration has recently imposed a 25% tariff on imports of steel, arguing that the tariff will protect the U.S. steel industry and ensure the competitiveness of steel manufacturing companies in the U.S. (refer to any article) Do you agree with the argument that the U.S. steel manufacturers will be able to maintain its competitiveness by the tariff? Pick one of the two options:-
If you do agree with the above argument: – Explain why you agree, with supporting evidence. In addition, explain your argument with the opposing argument (“do not agree”) in mind. – Pick a U.S. company in another industry that is related to the steel manufacturing industry (competitor, buyer or supplier of the steel manufacturing industry, or any other company in another industry) that you believe will be negatively impacted by the tariff, and explain why (elaborate and show evidence). Given that the company (outside of the steel manufacturing industry) might be negatively impacted by the tariff, what would be a strategic option for the company to become competitive? Use either the 5 Forces model (with a full analysis using the 5-Forces worksheet) or VRIO model (full analysis of a resource/capability using the indicators – change of revenue/cost for V, providing a sense of R, using first-mover advantage, path dependence, social complexity, causal ambiguity, patents for I, and reporting/control/compensation for O) to support your argument, using evidence.
– If you don’t agree with the argument, implying that U.S. steel manufacturers will not be able to maintain its competitiveness by the tariff: – Explain why you don’t agree with the argument, with supporting evidence. In addition, explain your argument with the opposing argument (“do agree”) in mind. – Pick a U.S. steel manufacturer, and explain how the company might increase and sustain its competitiveness. Write an analysis, using either the 5 Forces model (full analysis of the industry indicating all of the 5 Forces) or VRIO model (full analysis of a resource/capability using the indicators – change of revenue/cost for V, providing a sense of R, using first-mover advantage, path dependence, social complexity, causal ambiguity, patents for I, and reporting/control/compensation for O) to support your argument, using evidence.